alright, on to my beef for the day. my profile is very clear: if you're poly / in a relationship / looking for an open relationship - do NOT message me. i'm also very clear that i'm looking for dating / a relationship, not the other options available like new friends / pen pals / or casual sex.
with that clearly stated, i think it's understandable why i'm pissed about the following message from a bi girl that's "available" and states right off the bat that she's poly and in a relationship and has a wonderful boyfriend blah blah blah....
How do you feel about poly people if all they're looking for is platonic interesting conversations over coffee? (This is how I expand my social circle, ;) )
i replied as bluntly as possible:
Poly people looking for platonic conversation, hmm....
I've been trying to write a response for the past hour and a half that doesn't make me look dismissive and bitter about past experiences with poly females that were just supposed to be "just friends" since I can't really convey tone, body language, etc. through email. With that little disclaimer, if you can bear with me through airing my concerns, I hope you'll understand my apprehensions.
1) Over the years, I've become acquainted with a number of poly individuals (male and female - more female though). I recognize that this limited number isn't representative of the poly community as a whole, and I'm trying not to judge it as such, but my experiences are what they are. Two supposedly "just friends" (both female & involved in open relationships) have tried on multiple occasions to get me to "oh, try it some time" or to persuade me into getting together at times where they were lonely and obviously looking for some sort of hook up ~ all while obviously dismissing the facts that I do not do anything casual (and yes, that's another issue entirely) and that I have no interest in being a part of a poly relationship or being with someone when they already have a partner. Again, I'm not trying to generalize to the community as a whole, but those have been two of my most recent experiences and it leaves me with a feeling that my preferences are not respected by those that don't understand my inability to participate in casual and/or non-monogamous relationships.
2) I have a fairly small circle of friends. Roughly 70% of which is female. A number of them are women that I was either:
a) interested in at some point, but rejected and "friendzoned" or
b) involved with and dated (anywhere from a few dates to 14yrs), but no longer together with.
While I try to be a good friend and support them, it's hard for me to not feel hurt, dismissed or rejected again when nearly all of them are in happy relationships and I'm still alone. Yes, there's a fair bit of selfishness there and I'm sure that they're not trying to rub my face in my failed efforts of the past, but it's still hard for me to deal with at times.
3) Kind of a corollary of 2) - I joined internet dating sites with the expressed intention of finding a relationship, since I thought that was the point of searching for individuals to date. The number of women who are only looking for new friends and pen-pals on here is very off-putting to me. We all have a limited amount of resources and time. At first, I tried to put a serious attempt in talking to women that approached me first (I will not message anyone that doesn't list "long-term dating" in their "looking for" section first) and trying to be friends with them and expand my social circle. So far, that has not gone particularly well - there have been a lot of mixed signals and hurt feelings as a result of those efforts. Plus, back to the point about limited resources - constantly trying to build new friendships takes time and effort. That's time and effort taken away from achieving my goal of finding a long-term partner...
So, yeah... Still sounds kind of dismissive and bitter, right? Having read through your profile twice and looking at some of our match questions, it seems like we could have some pretty solid conversations - but, I have no idea if that offsets my apprehensions above. I recognize how this reply must seem, but I hope that you can see and (at least partially) understand my point of view.
which brings a snarky reply from her:
Yes, you are correct in how it sounds. I can see your point of view, but am not interested in lowering my personal utility to deal with it.
Good luck in your search though. Have you considered match.com? It might be a better fit for what you're looking for.
needless to say, i'm annoyed as fuck. i've been nothing but honest in my profile and have listed a few conditions that are absolute deal-breakers for me, and yet - i'm still messaged by individuals that don't respect my preferences...